*This image represents the intended product however, bottle designs, artwork, packaging and current batch release or proof may be updated from the producer without notice.

Where to buy Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum 12 Year Old Straight Rye Whiskey

Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum 12 Year Old Straight Rye Whiskey

$749.99
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Whiskey: Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum 12 Year Old Straight Rye Whiskey

This bottle will make a fine addition to any whisky lover.

Order from the Largest & Most Trusted Premium Spirits Marketplace!

Featured in

  • ROLLING STONE
  • MEN'S JOURNAL
  • US WEEKLY

ALL ORDERS PLACED ARE GUARANTEED and WILL NOT be cancelled like with other retailers. Many other small liquor store sites will end up cancelling your order due to the high demand and unavailability.

Size: 750ML

Proof: 101.5 (50.75%ABV)

Origin: United States

Distillery: Penelope

Detailed Description

Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum is a 12-year-old straight rye whiskey selected for its mature character and layered flavor profile. Distilled in Indiana from a high-rye mash bill of 95% rye and 5% malted barley, it spends over a decade maturing in charred American oak barrels. The extended aging brings together classic rye spice with rich toffee, dark fruit, and developed oak character. Bottled at 101.5 proof, it offers a balance of concentrated flavor, herbal freshness, and warming spice, showcasing the depth that well-aged rye can achieve.

Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum 12 Year Old Straight Rye Whiskey Tasting Notes

Nose: Fresh mint, ripe cherry, and baking spices mingle with toasted oak, caramel, and hints of dark fruit.

Palate: Toffee and caramel lead into dark cherry, clove, and cracked black pepper. Herbal mint and rye spice provide freshness, while mature oak adds structure and a gently earthy character.

Finish: Medium to long, with lingering black pepper, mint, toasted oak, and dark chocolate, rounded out by a subtle caramel sweetness.

Distillery Information

Penelope Bourbon was founded in 2018 by Mike Paladini and his partners, with a focus on blending and presenting distinctive American whiskeys. The brand built its reputation by sourcing whiskey from established distilleries and creating blends designed to emphasize balance, flavor, and approachability. Penelope became part of MGP Ingredients' spirits portfolio following its acquisition by the company in 2023. Its approach combines blending expertise with experimentation across mash bills, maturation methods, and finishing casks. The brand continues to develop a varied range of bourbons and rye whiskeys while maintaining its focus on flavor-driven whiskey making.

Notice

DISCLAIMER** This is a single item listing unless otherwise noted in the description. Retailer advises either in stock or in route to their location. Usually ships within one to four business days. Longer processing times may occur especially around holiday(s). Some items may become backordered or delayed without notice due to demand & will ship out upon arrival. Overseas 700ml products typically have longer processing/transit times. You can always verify product availability by calling 1-888-548-0333 or chat with a Shopping Advisor. Our site terms state that customs import duties and taxes are the buyer’s responsibility. Please refer to our cancellations & returns agreement or reach out to our support team at help@caskcartel.com for any additional questions.

Dedicated Concierge

Our dedicated team specializes in creating personalized shopping experiences. If you’re looking for a specific item or collection that isn’t appearing on our marketplace, please reach out to us at concierge@caskcartel.com or fill out the product inquiry form and one of our dedicated team members will be in touch. Whether it’s a product you’ve experienced while traveling or a rare, hard to find item you’ve been searching for, we have an established global network of retailers with the ability to locate and source the rarest and hardest to find products.

Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum 12 Year Old Straight Rye Whiskey at CaskCartel.com
ConciergeUK

Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum 12 Year Old Straight Rye Whiskey

$749.99

Whiskey: Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum 12 Year Old Straight Rye Whiskey

This bottle will make a fine addition to any whisky lover.

Order from the Largest & Most Trusted Premium Spirits Marketplace!

Featured in

ALL ORDERS PLACED ARE GUARANTEED and WILL NOT be cancelled like with other retailers. Many other small liquor store sites will end up cancelling your order due to the high demand and unavailability.

Size: 750ML

Proof: 101.5 (50.75%ABV)

Origin: United States

Distillery: Penelope

Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum is a 12-year-old straight rye whiskey selected for its mature character and layered flavor profile. Distilled in Indiana from a high-rye mash bill of 95% rye and 5% malted barley, it spends over a decade maturing in charred American oak barrels. The extended aging brings together classic rye spice with rich toffee, dark fruit, and developed oak character. Bottled at 101.5 proof, it offers a balance of concentrated flavor, herbal freshness, and warming spice, showcasing the depth that well-aged rye can achieve.

Penelope Estate Collection Conundrum 12 Year Old Straight Rye Whiskey Tasting Notes

Nose: Fresh mint, ripe cherry, and baking spices mingle with toasted oak, caramel, and hints of dark fruit.

Palate: Toffee and caramel lead into dark cherry, clove, and cracked black pepper. Herbal mint and rye spice provide freshness, while mature oak adds structure and a gently earthy character.

Finish: Medium to long, with lingering black pepper, mint, toasted oak, and dark chocolate, rounded out by a subtle caramel sweetness.

Distillery Information

Penelope Bourbon was founded in 2018 by Mike Paladini and his partners, with a focus on blending and presenting distinctive American whiskeys. The brand built its reputation by sourcing whiskey from established distilleries and creating blends designed to emphasize balance, flavor, and approachability. Penelope became part of MGP Ingredients' spirits portfolio following its acquisition by the company in 2023. Its approach combines blending expertise with experimentation across mash bills, maturation methods, and finishing casks. The brand continues to develop a varied range of bourbons and rye whiskeys while maintaining its focus on flavor-driven whiskey making.

View product